Collies and kelpies, two of Australia’s most popular working dog breeds, have a long-standing rivalry among fans and owners. With distinct characteristics, these breeds are put to the test in season three of ABC iview’s Muster Dogs to determine the champion muster dog.
When it comes to choosing between a kelpie and a collie as a pet, there are key differences to consider. Kelpies are known for their black and tan coloring, while collies traditionally have black and white coats. Additionally, kelpies are considered more instinctual working dogs, while collies are viewed as more trainable and social.
In the view of collie breeder Mick Hudson, collies are highly trainable, whereas kelpies possess natural abilities that make them adept at learning tasks on their own. Both breeds have their strengths, and the choice between them is akin to choosing between different car brands, according to Mick.
Veteran dog trainer Neil McDonald emphasizes the importance of matching a dog’s qualities with the owner’s personality. Border collies, with their preference for structure and organization, suit individuals who appreciate order, while kelpies, known for their adaptability, may be better suited for those with a more laid-back approach.
Stock manager and kelpie breeder Blake Robinson acknowledges that while kelpies can make great pets, they require mental stimulation to prevent destructive behavior. On the other hand, sheep farmer Donna Smith, who breeds border collies, finds collies to be more affectionate and better suited as pets for most people.
Animal behaviorist Dr. Kate Mornement advises that owners of working dog breeds like collies and kelpies should understand and redirect their dogs’ natural instincts, which have been honed over generations. She stresses the importance of providing adequate exercise and socialization for these dogs, especially when transitioning from rural to urban environments.
Ultimately, the debate between collies and kelpies as the better pet continues among enthusiasts like Blake and Donna. While each breed has its unique qualities, the decision on which makes the best pet depends on individual preferences and lifestyle considerations. Catch the new season of Muster Dogs: Collies and Kelpies to see which breed is crowned the champion muster dog.
📰 Related Articles
- Top Registrars for .AI Domains: Choosing Your Ideal Partner
- Meet Nick: Military Working Dog Symbolizes Dedication and Valor
- Jetstar vs. Qantas: Choosing the Best Flight to Phuket
- HP OMEN vs. Custom Builds: Ideal Gaming PC for Australians
- Guide to Choosing Home Printers: Inkjet vs. Laser Options